When Promises Of Marriage Turn Consensual Sex Into Rape? 91-8877001993

Legal and social dilemmas in India, especially with regard to consent and sex relationships, intersect law and morality with society mores, which highly complicates the issues. Several debates rage in this context but the most significant is whether consensual sex under promise to marry can be treated legally as rape in certain situations.

Why in the News?

• A recent Supreme Court judgment has cleared up the fog regarding ground rules under which a consensual sexual relationship may amount to rape due to false promise to marry.
• The Court observed that when a woman has been long physically in a relationship with a man, it cannot be conclusively assumed that the relationship is only based on promise of the man to marry her. Further it stated that a woman may indulge into an extramarital relationship for reasons other than promise of marriage.
• To constitute the offence of rape by false pretext of marriage, it must be shown that the sexual relationship was predicated on promissory marriage alone, and the consent obtained from her was rendered invalid due to misconception of fact when he later retracted from the promise.

Facts of the Case

In the case of Mahesh Damu Khare vs. The State of Maharashtra:

• A woman has filed an FIR against a man for the crime of rape, after their breakdown of relationship.
• The man argued that the relationship was consensual and has rejected the allegations, stating that they were made only after the cessation of monetary support to the complainant.
• The Court has refused to accept the demand of the complainant that the appellant had attempted to have sexual intercourse with her under the guise of false promise to marry.

Observation of the Court

• One who makes a false promise of marriage would amount to a man being accused of a sexual relationship. 
• The criminal liability in such a case would be required to establish a link between the physical relations and the false promise of marriage and not from any other source or circumstance. 
• The woman may pursue some pretty healthy physical liaisons without the promise of marriage from the man due to reasons other than proof that he is boyfriend material.

Challenges in Determining Consent

Marriage promises involve questions of consent that are pivotal. The Indian courts have taken a fine approach in drawing lines between consent given voluntarily and under a mis-conception of fact; however, this comes with its challenges.

• Burden of Proving Misrepresentation: It is difficult to prove that the promise was made without any intention to satisfy it; such proof has to be circumstantial most of which is dubious. Thus, the grey area is likely to give rise to both false allegations and denial of justice.
• Evolving Age Norms: With this generation being more open-minded about relationships and premarital sex, the idea of applying the old law principles to modern relationships is becoming more complex. What constitutes "misconception of fact" again depends on whose shoes are being worn and where in the world one falls.
• Gender Impact: The law in question would apply to women-in-law; however, it would for some cases continue to reinforce patriarchal norms by seeing women as victims of deception rather than as autonomous entities making informed choices.

Balancing Legal Protections and Autonomy

• Clear Definitions: The law should define "misconception of fact" and provide some proper guidelines to differentiate between real relationship and false promise.
• Gender Neutral Laws: Laws regarding consent and promises of marriage should be made flexible because human relations are dynamics, and so that equality is ensured and misuse of provisions prevented.
• Awareness and Education: Conversations on consent, autonomy, and healthy relationships must be encouraged, as it can greatly reduce misunderstandings and exploitation. These include education on the legal implications of promises of marriage.
• Support Systems: There should be strong protection systems for women ostracized from the society because of unsuccessful relationships. This such counselling, legal aid, and social rehabilitation programs.

Marriage promises leading to consensual sexual activity becoming rape speak volumes about the intricate relationship between law, morality, and societal demands in India. While protective legislation defines the exploitation to which a person must not be subjected, it has to balance this with fairness and prevention of misuse. This calls for a nuanced understanding of relationships, changing social norms, and, therefore, the role of individuality within them. As society evolves in every way, so must its laws and attitudes on matters of consent and personal agency to ensure justice for all without treading the old tracks of morality. 

Sharks of Law offers a comprehensive legal solutions facility, providing an extensive collection of information on diverse areas of law and current developments in the legal field by the best professionals in this area. With this law firm, you can search and find a lawyer who can meet your legal requirements for online consultation. The attorneys at Sharks of Law have the necessary expertise across all the fields involved should you have any inquiries that require legal counsel.

Email:-helpdesk@sharksoflaw.com

Help Desk:-+91-8877001993