Sharks of Law
Adv Shubham Jindal
Adv Shubham Jindal. | 7 months ago | 271 Views

Financial Position Of The Employer To Be Considered When Deciding Wage Structure Of The Employees- SC

While passing a recent judgement in the case of The VVF Ltd. Employees Union v. M/s. VVF India Limited & Anr., the Supreme Court of India stressed that an employer’s financial capacity shall be considered as one of the deciding factors when calculating the wage structure of the employees.

While deciding an appeal against the judgement of the Bombay High Court, the Bench of Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sanjay Kumar, observed that the best course in the present case would have been to remit the matter to the Industrial Tribunal by the High Court.

Background of the Case-

  • The main issue of the case is regarding the demands raised by the Appellant, i.e. the Employee’s Union in the year 2008, regarding the revision of the pay scale as well as certain allowances.  
  • The Tribunal granted certain relief to the employees, which was challenged in the  Bombay High Court by both parties, i.e. the Union and the employer 
  • The High Court allowed 4 demands by the Union, while the decision of the Tribunal was allowed for 7 demands.
  • The appellant, i.e. the Union filed a review petition against the judgement by the High Court, which was dismissed. Finally, 3 appeals were filed in the Supreme Court of India.

Submissions by Parties

  • The Employer contended that the High Court when judging the legality of the award could not have enquired about the facts and the evidence, also that the units which were compared with the employer were not placed in a similar situation, i.e. their financial position and their industrial output.
  • Also, the employer stressed that the negative financial stratus of the employer was ignored by the High Court on the ground that losses were ‘miniscule’, granting some allowances in the absence of any evidence.
  • The Union on the other hand presented that provided under Article 226, instead of remanding a matter, the High Court has jurisdiction to decide upon the facts.

Observations by Supreme Court

  • The Supreme Court Bench, referred to the judgement given in the case of Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd. and Others v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha and Others, to conclude that in appropriate cases, the High Courts could examine the facts as well when deciding upon the award of a Tribunal.
  • It was also observed by the Apex Court that when deciding upon the revision of the wages, the industrial educator must follow the standard criteria, applying the industry-cum-region test, according to which the pay and allowances for a case must be compared with an equally placed unit in the same region.
  • The Supreme Court also noticed that as decided in the case of A.K. Bindal v. Union of India & Ors. and Mukand Ltd. v. Mukand Staff & Officers Association, when deciding upon the comparability of units, one must consider the financial capacity of the employer. 
  • Also, as the employer presented that he was facing losses and the High Court asked for fresh charts, it would have been appropriate to remand the matter to the Tribunal.
  • As for about the jurisdiction of the High Court to decide upon the facts of the matter again, the Apex Court said that appreciation of the evidence by the High Court was not proper and even the plea filed by the employee-Union's for provisions related to the overtime wages when counting the allowance, had to be re-examined.

Decision by the Apex Court

The Supreme Court of India, setting aside the award by the Tribunal as well as the judgement of the High Court, decided that the matter must be decided by the Tribunal in fresh proceedings within a period of 6 months.

Sharks of Law offers you experienced lawyers who have been dealing with both civil as well as criminal matters at lower courts as well as the High Court and Supreme Court, and could offer you necessary legal counsel as required in case you are dealing with issues related to labour law or matters related to employer-employee matters.

Email:-helpdesk@sharksoflaw.com

Help Desk:-+91-88770-01993

Other Articles You May Enjoy

The Epic Saga of The Ayodhya Verdict: Pran Pratishtha to Be Held Today!

Super admin • 22/01/2024

What is arbitration and its types?

Super admin • 31/01/2024

Key Principles Adopted By The Court In The Ram Janmabhoomi Case

Super admin • 01/02/2024

What Do You Mean By Legal Drafting?

Super admin • 02/02/2024

The Rise Of Virtual Mediation: How Online Platforms Are Reshaping Divorce Proceedings

Super admin • 03/02/2024

Madhya Pradesh: Woman Files For Divorce After Husband Took Her To Ayodhya Instead Of Goa For Honeymoon

Super admin • 04/02/2024

Expert Insights From Local Divorce Lawyers And The Rise Of Online Divorce Services

Super admin • 05/02/2024

What Is The Procedure Of Mutation?

Super admin • 06/02/2024

What are the basic methods of legal drafting?

Super admin • 07/02/2024

Interim Maintenance To Wife If No Adherence To Decree Of Restitution Of Conjugal Rights

Super admin • 09/02/2024

What Is The Punishment In Cheque Bounce Case?

Super admin • 11/02/2024

Woman Seeks Divorce Over Mother-In-Law Using Makeup

Super admin • 12/02/2024

Key Legal Aspects Concerning Farmer’s Protest 2.0

Super admin • 13/02/2024

Supreme Court Confuses Tinder With Kindle

Super admin • 14/02/2024

Kisan Andolan 2.0- Reasons, Demand And Strategy For Protests After 2 Years?

Super admin • 15/02/2024

Halting Of Paytm Payment Bank By Rbi

Super admin • 16/02/2024

In Which Countries Abortion Is Legal?

Super admin • 16/02/2024

ELECTORAL BOND SCHEME: BANNED

Super admin • 17/02/2024

What are the three agricultural laws that farmers are protesting against

Super admin • 17/02/2024

Electoral Bonds Scheme Declared Unconstitutional By The Sc

Super admin • 19/02/2024

Difference between charge sheet and FIR

Super admin • 19/02/2024

Supreme Court Strikes Down Controversial Electoral Bond Scheme

Super admin • 20/02/2024

Citing The Unborn’s Right To Life, High Court Recalls Its Order Of Terminating A 29 Weeks Pregnancy

Super admin • 21/02/2024

Rs 800 Crores approve for Expansion of Supreme Court Complex: Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Super admin • 23/02/2024

What are the principles of drafting?

Super admin • 24/02/2024

Pregnancy Among Women Prisoners Within Jail: Ban Of Male Staff Members

Super admin • 27/02/2024

Top Law Firm In Delhi: Sharks Of Law

Super admin • 27/02/2024

Medical Negligence: Awarding of Compensation for Unsuccessful Eye Surgery

Super admin • 28/02/2024

ED Starts Investigating Paytm Bank Over Foreign Exchange Violations

Super admin • 28/02/2024

Registration Of Live-In Relationship

Super admin • 29/02/2024

How Do You Draft A Legal Document?

Super admin • 29/02/2024

Ayush Wellness Center Opens At Supreme Court Premises

Super admin • 01/03/2024

Promote the wellness of Judges: Ayush Wellness Centres

Super admin • 02/03/2024

Ayush Hwc Inaugurated By The Cji In Supreme Court Premises

Adv Tanvi Malik • 03/03/2024

From Goa Beach Expectations To Ayodhya Realities: Mp Woman Moves The Court By Filing Divorce Case

Adv Tanvi Malik • 03/03/2024

What Is The Punishment For A Cybercrime Complaint?

Adv Tanvi Malik • 05/03/2024

What Is The Illegal Termination Of Employees?

Adv Tanvi Malik • 05/03/2024

Gang Rapes- Common Trends In India ?

Adv Tanvi Malik • 06/03/2024

What Is A Chargesheet?

Adv Arjun Sharma • 06/03/2024

Spanish Tourist Gang-Raped In Dumka Jharkhand

Adv Tanvi Malik • 07/03/2024

Demolition Of A 600-Year-Old Mosque- Delhi High Court Asks DDA If Any Prior Notice Was Given

Adv Shifa • 08/03/2024

Warning Against Digital House Arrest

Adv Aditya • 09/03/2024

No Government Jobs For Family With More Than Two Children

Adv Tanvi Malik • 09/03/2024

How To Recover Your Loaned Money ?

Adv Shifa • 10/03/2024

Electoral Bonds Case: SBI Demands Extension From Supreme Court

Adv Tanvi Malik • 12/03/2024

CJI Chandrachud Fears Bail Becoming The Exception

Adv Shifa • 12/03/2024

CAA Before Elections By Modi Govt

Adv Tanvi Malik • 13/03/2024

What Is Workmen's Compensation Insurance?

Adv Shubham Jindal • 14/03/2024

Dolma Aunty Momos: A Flavorful Victory In The Trademark Arena!

Adv Tanvi Malik • 17/03/2024

Legal Insights: Dashrath Sahu v. State Of Chhattisgarh - Recent Supreme Court Ruling

Adv Shubham Jindal • 17/03/2024

Termination V Resignation

Adv Tanvi Malik • 18/03/2024

किसान आंदोलन 2.0 - 2 साल बाद विरोध प्रदर्शन का कारण, मांग और रणनीति?

Adv Arjun Sharma • 18/03/2024

Official Notification For CAA Issued After 4 Years !!

Adv Shifa • 19/03/2024

हरियाणा सरकार किसानों के प्रदर्शन के तरीके से आपत्ति जताते हुए हाई कोर्ट पहुंची।

Adv Tanvi Malik • 20/03/2024

Benefits Of Workmen Compensation Policy

Adv Arjun Sharma • 21/03/2024

Is Anticipatory Bail Possible In 498A Cases ?

Adv Ankit Kansal • 24/03/2024

Top Divorce Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shifa • 27/03/2024

SC Upholds Two-Child Policy For Government Jobs In Rajasthan

Adv Arjun Sharma • 28/03/2024

Supreme Court To Hear SBI Application For Extension Of Time In Electoral Bond Matter

Adv kanchan kumari • 29/03/2024

Female Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 31/03/2024

Best Criminal Lawyer In Delhi NCR

Adv Arjun Sharma • 31/03/2024

Famous Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 01/04/2024

Top 10 Lawyers In Delhi High Court

Adv Shubham Jindal • 01/04/2024

Best Lawyers In Delhi For Divorce

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 02/04/2024

Best Criminal Lawyers In The Supreme Court

Adv Rahul Pandey • 03/04/2024

Best Criminal Lawyers In Delhi High Court

Adv Samman Singh • 04/04/2024

KATCHATHEEVU Island- Controversy Behind It ?

Adv Anshul Jain • 05/04/2024

Lawyers Role In The Development Of Startup

Adv Tanvi Malik • 08/04/2024

AAP Candidate New Mayor Of Chandigarh, SC Decides

Adv Shifa • 08/04/2024

Registration of CAA: Documents required

Adv Aditya • 08/04/2024

Types Of Motor Insurance In India

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 09/04/2024

In Maintenance Cases Courts May Make Small Guess Work When Concluding Income Of Husband From Unorganised Sector.

Adv Rahul Pandey • 10/04/2024

Labour Court Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Samman Singh • 11/04/2024

Immigration Lawyers In Delhi

Adv kanchan kumari • 12/04/2024

Army Nurse Terminated For Marriage, Awarded 60 Lakhs As Damages

Adv Shubham Jindal • 15/04/2024

Dolma Aunty Momos Claims Trademark Victory

Adv Ankit Kansal • 16/04/2024

GST Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Arjun Sharma • 18/04/2024

Controversial “ANTI-HINDU” Temple Tax Bill Finally Defeated In The Karnataka Legislative Council

Adv Samman Singh • 18/04/2024

What Does Motor Vehicle Accident Insurance Cover?

Adv Anshul Jain • 19/04/2024

What Is The Purpose Of The Motor Vehicle Insurance Act?

Adv kanchan kumari • 19/04/2024

At Home Lawyer Consultation Near Me

Adv Kanishk Garg • 20/04/2024

ED Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 22/04/2024

Corporate Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shubham Jindal • 22/04/2024

Civil Court’s Ruling Binding On Criminal Court For Certain Limited Purpose Only-SC

Adv Rahul Pandey • 24/04/2024

Legal Consultation At My Doorstep: Can Advocate Visit My Home?

Adv Samman Singh • 25/04/2024

TAX Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 30/04/2024

Best Insurance Law Firm In India

Adv Rahul Pandey • 01/05/2024

How Long Is Anticipatory Bail Valid?

Adv Kanishk Garg • 01/05/2024

Can A Lawyer Visit My Place To Provide Me Legal Advice ?

Adv Anshul Jain • 03/05/2024

How Is Compensation Calculated In Motor Accident Claims?

Adv Shifa • 03/05/2024

How To Complain Online About Cybercrimes ?

Adv Tanvi Malik • 04/05/2024

Domestic Violence Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 06/05/2024

Insolvency Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Ankit Kansal • 07/05/2024

Mutual Divorce Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Rahul Pandey • 08/05/2024

Trademark Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Kanishk Garg • 08/05/2024

Supreme Court Directs To Act Responsibly Against Misleading Advertisements

Adv Anshul Jain • 10/05/2024

Role Of Lawyer In An Insurance Company?

Adv Shifa • 10/05/2024

Difference Between Lease And A Rent Agreement ?

Adv Shubham Jindal • 13/05/2024

Delhi Police Lawyer : Their Role And Importance

Adv Rahul Pandey • 15/05/2024

Documentation Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Arjun Sharma • 16/05/2024

Custody Rights Of Maternal Grandmother Of A Muslim Girl Child

Adv Anshul Jain • 17/05/2024

Best Family Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shifa • 18/05/2024

Divorce Lawyers In Rohini Court Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 18/05/2024

Supreme Court Directed Equal Responsibility Of Advertisers And Endorsers In Misleading ADS.

Adv Shubham Jindal • 20/05/2024

Arbitration Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 20/05/2024

Custody Rights Muslim Girl Not Attained Puberty After Mother's Death

Adv Anshul Jain • 25/05/2024

The Shocking Incident Of Pune Porsche Car Crash

Adv Tanvi Malik • 27/05/2024

Consult With Best Insurance Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shubham Jindal • 27/05/2024

Immigration Lawyers In Delhi:-Why Hire One ?

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 28/05/2024

Dispute Resolution And Arbitration Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Ankit Kansal • 28/05/2024

Child Custody Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Rahul Pandey • 29/05/2024

Mandatory Video Conference Hearings At All District Courts

Adv Arjun Sharma • 30/05/2024

Delhi High Court Directs Videoconferencing Of All Proceedings At District Courts

Adv Tanvi Malik • 01/06/2024

Role Of NCLT Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Samman Singh • 01/06/2024

Role Of Panel For Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Arjun Sharma • 06/06/2024

US Immigration Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 07/06/2024

The Role Of Army Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 10/06/2024

Best Consumer Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Shubham Jindal • 10/06/2024

Role Of Human Rights Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 11/06/2024

MACT Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Ankit Kansal • 11/06/2024

Role Of DRT Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Rahul Pandey • 13/06/2024

NDPS Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Kanishk Garg • 13/06/2024

Domestic Violence Lawyers In Delhi NCR

Adv Anshul Jain • 14/06/2024

Employment Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shifa • 14/06/2024

How To Find The Best Lawyer In India?

Adv Anshul Jain • 21/06/2024

AFT Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Samman Singh • 21/06/2024

SC Sent Notice To NTA And Centre Over NEET-UG Row

Adv Tanvi Malik • 22/06/2024

Status Of Live In Relationship In India?

Adv Shifa • 22/06/2024

Top Lawyers In India

Adv Tanvi Malik • 24/06/2024

Environmental Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Shubham Jindal • 24/06/2024

Doctrine Of Merger Not Universal In Application, Article 142 Powers An Exception: Supreme Court

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 25/06/2024

How To Get Free Legal Advice Online?

Adv Ankit Kansal • 25/06/2024

Suppression Of Facts Requires Severe Measures: Supreme Court Drops SLP At Rs. 25k Expense

Adv Rahul Pandey • 26/06/2024

What Is Revision Under Section 397 Of CRPC And Its Limitation

Adv Samman Singh • 27/06/2024

Is There A Time Limit For Filing Complaints Regarding OMR Sheets Under NEET-UG 2024? Supreme Court Requests NTA

Adv Anshul Jain • 28/06/2024

Top Consumer Lawyer In Delhi

Adv Samman Singh • 28/06/2024

Military Lawyers In Delhi

Adv Tanvi Malik • 29/06/2024

New Laws In Force From July 1st, 2024: Major Changes In Criminal Laws

Adv Tanvi Malik • 02/07/2024

Registration Of A New Case In Delhi Under New Criminal Laws

Adv Shubham Jindal • 02/07/2024

Engineer Rashid Is Granted Parole By A Delhi Court So That He Can Swear In As Baramulla MP

Adv Rahul Pandey • 03/07/2024

Top Female Lawyers In India

Adv Kanishk Garg • 03/07/2024

CBI Issues NBW To Vijay Malaya

Adv Samman Singh • 04/07/2024

The Role Of Advocate For Company Law Matters

Adv Tanvi Malik • 06/07/2024

How To Find The Best Law Firm In Delhi?

Adv Tanvi Malik • 08/07/2024

Best Advocates In Delhi High Court

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 09/07/2024

What Are The Qualities Of Best Advocates?

Adv Ankit Kansal • 09/07/2024

Legal Consultation From Best Lawyers In Delhi And Gurgaon

Adv Arjun Sharma • 11/07/2024

In Patanjali Matter, IMA Notifies Supreme Court That It Has Apologized In Full Page For Remarks Made By Its President

Adv Ankit Kansal • 12/07/2024

Proposal To Include Manusmriti Readings In Law Courses at Delhi University Rejected

Adv Tanvi Malik • 15/07/2024

Supreme Court hearing On NEET Time

Adv Shubham Jindal • 15/07/2024

What Are The Duties Of A Lawyer

Adv Ankit Kansal • 16/07/2024

How To Find The Best Law Firm In Chandigarh?

Adv Arjun Sharma • 18/07/2024

Best Law Firm In Yamuna Nagar

Adv Samman Singh • 18/07/2024

Supreme Court Decision On Pension Today

Adv Anshul Jain • 19/07/2024

Matrimonial Lawyers In Chandigarh

Adv Shifa • 19/07/2024

NEET-UG 2024 Results Released Centre-Wise Following The Order Of The Supreme Court

Adv Tanvi Malik • 22/07/2024

Supreme Court Decides That Names Cannot Be Displayed At Dhabas Along The Kanwar Yatra Routes

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 23/07/2024

The Supreme Court Has Declined To Retest The NEET-UG 2024 Exam

Adv Rahul Pandey • 24/07/2024

BCI Has 6 Weeks Time To Decide On Payment Of Minimum Stipend For Junior Lawyers- Delhi HC

Adv Tanvi Malik • 29/07/2024

Kolkata Rape Murder Case What Happened Till Date

Adv Arjun Sharma • 29/08/2024

Observations By The Supreme Court On Kolkata Rape:-Murder Case

Adv Anshul Jain • 30/08/2024

Court Marriage Process In Delhi +91-88770-01993

Adv Shifa • 07/09/2024

Ujjain: Woman Raped In Daylight, While Passerby Recorded The Video, Rape Accused And Another Arrested +91-88770-01993

Adv Arjun Sharma • 07/09/2024

How To Apply For A Marriage Certificate ? +91-8877001993

Adv Tanvi Malik • 09/09/2024

How Is Murder Punishable? 8877001993

Adv Arjun Sharma • 14/09/2024

Cheque Bounce Lawyers In Delhi 91-8877001993

Adv Rahul Pandey • 18/09/2024

Dowry Death And Its Punishment 91-8877001993

Adv Samman Singh • 19/09/2024

How To Escape From Cheque Bounce Cases ?91-8877001993

Adv Anshul Jain • 20/09/2024

Arrest Of RG Kar Principal And Kolkata Cop By CBI +91-8877001993

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 24/09/2024

Arvind Kejriwal Resignation From The Post Of CM In Delhi

Adv Ankit Kansal • 24/09/2024

Improper Bathing Habits Of Husband Leads To Divorce +91-8877001993

Adv Rahul Pandey • 25/09/2024

Bail Of Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal In Delhi Excise Policy Case

Adv Kanishk Garg • 25/09/2024

Beef Found In Tirupati Ladoo Prasad +91-8877001993

Adv Anshul Jain • 27/09/2024

Section 125 Of CRPC Is Not There To Create An Army Of Idlers, Well-Qualified Wife Shall Not Solely Depend Upon Maintenance:- Mp High Court 91-8877001993

Adv Tanvi Malik • 28/09/2024

Resignation Not Final Until Employer Communicates The Acceptance To Employee:-SC 91-8877001993

Adv Shifa • 28/09/2024

High Court Condemns "Freebie Culture," Summons MCD Commissioner In Response To Delhi IAS Coaching Center Fatalities 91-8877001993

Adv Tanvi Malik • 30/09/2024

Role Of The Best Family Lawyers In Delhi +91-8877001993

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 01/10/2024

Can’t Call Religion Of India As Pakistan: Supreme Court Blasts Karnataka Judge

Adv Ankit Kansal • 01/10/2024

Death Sentence For Rape And Murder Of 7 Year Old Girl In Kolkata 91-8877001993

Adv Shifa • 05/10/2024

Delhi High Court Grants Pregnancy Termination In Live In Relationship 91-8877001993

Adv Ankit Kansal • 05/10/2024

Living Separately For Jobs Does Not Amount To Desertion 91-8877001993

Adv Kanishk Garg • 09/10/2024

What To Do In Cheque Bounce Case: Lawyers Legal Advice 91-8877001993

Adv Samman Singh • 10/10/2024

Govt Pleas For Criminalizing Marital Rapes?

Adv Tanvi Malik • 14/10/2024

Maintenance To Woman In Live In Relationship 91-8877001993

Adv Ankit Kansal • 15/10/2024

Baba Siddiqui Murder Case And Lawrence:-Bishnoi Gang Connection

Adv Anshul Jain • 18/10/2024

All Arrest And Detentions Are Not Custodial Torture 91-8877001993

Adv Samman Singh • 07/11/2024

New Appointment Cannot Be Revoked If Resignation Is Accepted By The Previous Company 91-8877001993

Adv Arjun Sharma • 09/11/2024

Matrimony Company To Pay Compensation To The Groom 91-8877001993

Adv Shubham Jindal • 11/11/2024

Justice Dy Chandrachud’s Legacy Through His 5 Key Judgments

Adv Ankit Kansal • 12/11/2024

Student Sues Jindal Global Law School After University Fails Him For Using 88% AI Generated Content In Exams 91-8877001993

Adv Arjun Sharma • 14/11/2024

Forcing Wife To Quit Job Amounts To Cruelty 91-8877001993

Adv Shubham Jindal • 25/11/2024

Celebrating The Spirit Of Democracy On Constitution Day On November 26

Adv Shubham Pahuja • 26/11/2024

Judicial Reform Through Set Up Of 24*7 Online Court In Kerela

Adv Anshul Jain • 06/12/2024

What To Do If A Police Officer Is Harassing You? 91-8877001993

Adv Arjun Sharma • 21/12/2024

Like what you see ? Follow us here
We Accept
Lawyer Account

Sign Up

Sign In

User Account

Sign Up

Sign In